Jellyfin direct play vs direct stream reddit

Jellyfin direct play vs direct stream reddit. It’s going to a Sonos Beam which doesn’t support EAC3. The reason I noticed is other services on my Pi start to become very slow. So I’ve asked a couple questions here before and a lot of people have chimed in to help out, but I still don’t know what’s wrong. You need the speed at least ~0. Oui sur mon PC nul de chez Boulanger 😂 ça tourne plutôt bien mais le transcodage est un vrai cauchemar du coup je regarde en Direct Play. I enabled debug logs, but are lucking of information, I would expect to get a at least the codec that is not supported. I have no issue on the Jellyfin MPV Desktop app. I am encountering a long running issue that I have thought I have solved multiple times at this point. If the movie needs to be transcoded, for example because of the subtitles or a DTS audio track, I have normal audio and everything works. Hello guys, I have a Raspberry pi 4 4gb with Openmediavault and Docker containers : radarr/sonarr/jellyfin etc with a USB 3. 8, now) and had no issues before. The info button will tell you if it is being transcoded and why. I confirmed by compiling MPV with the latest libs and sure enough it works. For the tuner I tried with 'Allow hardware transcoding' enabled and disabled. g. The goal is to Direct Play all media. As for the new AV1 HW encoder in DG2/Arc, the required changes have just been merged into the ffmpeg mainline serval days ago. After much internal discussion amongst the project members and leadership, we have decided to end our subreddit blackout, but leave r/jellyfin read-only, indefinitely. The article pretty much said trash all the existing settings and create new profiles for all media and codecs across all tabs. Forced : No. Since beginning, I have issue with slow direct play using jellyfin for kodi in addon mode. The settings layout is a bit different per device, but it should be something along the lines of Settings > Video > Remote video quality. As far as I know I haven't changed anything, and now playback freezes for ~2 seconds every ~5 seconds. Keep in mind that enabling subtitles usually triggers video-transcoding. The container is the file structure containing the encoded video and audio streams, plus any included subtitles or other extras. HEVC support is dependent on the Roku hardware, not the software. Hey guys, I have been really enjoying Jellyfin, and honestly it preforms fairly well. My setup is as follows: Client1: Chromecast with Google TV. This has the effect of making interacting with it feel very much like vanilla Kodi with local media (shows up under Movies/TV Shows on the home screen by default, virtually no delay, etc). Overall, I would say Plex takes the win for more polished interface, library scanning with less resources and overall better performance. When transcoding, limit at most to 1080p - 10 MBPS So best way in the end is to watch everything with Jellyfin Media Player and the apps. org. Jellyfin: easy setup, easy to access from home, takes some tinkering/port fowarding/reverse proxy/wireguard or tailscale to remotely access. You can increase the quality to above the original bitrate to fix this. If the media is incompatible for any reason, Jellyfin will use FFmpeg to convert the media to a format that the client can process. jellyfin. Reading a bit, I tried enabling the Allow video playback that requires conversion without re-encoding option. Another option is the MPV-Shim client, which should also direct play nearly everything that I know of. Direct Streaming a file uses very little processing power Jellyfin reads the file into memory and then streams it to the client where as SMB streams it directly via the SMB storage protocol. When I run plex with my other 10 containers, cpu usage is at 5-7% and ram usage is at 1. Mar 27, 2019 · In this case, the file can be Direct Streamed to your device. I have been using jellyfin for quite long time. Feb 9, 2024 · I'm having issues playing certain files on my TV through the jellyfin app, the below is LOTR and this doesn't play at all. Jellyfin has lots of additional features - I've just migrated to it from using Kodi alone - like easy remote access and having multiple users/ accounts. The native PS5 app can play H265/HEVC files directly, can play up to Dolby Digital Plus natively, and can play regular SRT files with no problem. Jellyfin supports arm64 so it works for you perfectly. If the video codec is unsupported, this will I just get no audio when I want to play a movie with a Dolby Digital 5. 265 10-bit media on my FireStick all the time, with Kodi. I have a Raspberry pi 4 with 8 GB because i use 4 GB on a ramdisk and then i have changed the cache and transcoding path in Jellyfin It also needs transcoding for adding the overlay icon, if you want it. Playing these video files in Kodi, I get direct play, no transcoding or direct streaming. I'm pretty sure that was the case, but it seems to be fixed now. Which means if Jellyfin support in infuse 6 dies at some point I'm left scrambling to help them find an alternative. I have an old repurposed laptop as a Jellyfin server and does not transcode super fast. If you want to test if it can play HEVC files, try loading a test file onto a USB thumb drive, plugging that into your TV and playing it with the Roku Media Player. Because I use multiple different devices as well as the other people on my server. 0 size=N/A time=00:00:20. Not 100% sure what you get when using tvheadend via jellyfin. Go to Settings > Status > Dashboard. Instead, we welcome you to join us at our new forum: https://forum. Could be direct streaming, which is converting audio only. Language : English. 10. plex. J'utilisais Emby aussi mais c'était une vrai galère pour partager des comptes avec les potes etc Donc je suis passé à Jellyfin, c'est pas parfait mais ça marche et c'est 100% gratuit ! Jellyfin can direct play properly using the fMP4-HLS setting. i was investigating a little longer and comparing tv shows that work and tv shows that does not work, also comparing it with movies that work and i found something common between the videos that work and the videos that does not work. Not as many clients have apps, but that is slowly growing. 8. All wired. Cheers! . I have to enable mpeg-2 direct play, then disable the maximum bandwidth setting to keep the video from being transcoded. internal network or Internet), compared against the limits set in the server settings. You probably using the PS4 app and not the native PS5 app. Both connected to router, which is connected to a 1Gb/s fibre line. This is important for me now because spatial audio works only when playing through safari right now. 264 8bit AAC? I would consider H. Should direct play most files. Like, 8bit vs 10bit vs 12bit color. After upgrading to 10. MPV just got dv5 support in their non stable branch. 1. is there a way to do the same in jellyfin? even if i have to modify something in the config files? Also jellyfin has free hardware transcoding. Rarely use the iOS app but can be handy. That means, if jellyfin-media-player gets a new playback feature it will most likely also be reflected in jellyfin-mpv-shim. The settings are the same across both sticks. Containers like MKV vs MP4. With regard to how JF decides to transcode or direct play, this will depend on the codecs supported by the platform and the type of connection (e. All equipment is connected via gigabit Kodi will generally direct play everything you can throw at it, so that would be a good option in this case. The Plex Media Server repackages the content on-the-fly before streaming it. Plex is the more mature of the two and has extra features like skip intro, skip credits, transcode+download and way more client support. Using an Nvidia Shield, running Kodi with Jellyfin plugin, accessing large 80Gb Remux HEVC ATMOS files from my Jellyfin server, which runs as a docker container on a Dell Optiplex 7040 i5 (6500 6th gen) machine playing the media off a usb3-connected we passport harddrive. I read that roku ultra and roku tv both does the conversion without the help of Jellyfin for Kodi - This addon syncs metadata from selected Jellyfin libraries into the local Kodi database. 264 8bit AAC? I've been watching a few shows on my phone (Android Jellyfin app) from my server (Windows 10. 0. While the player is still waiting to transcode but before it gives up, you can log in to the server dashboard Dec 21, 2023 · A universal 'force direct play' feature would also simplify the video aspects of playing a remux. ass subtitles, so i am forced to enable transcoding to burn them in the video. Basically 99% of the features that plex has, free of charge. EDIT 2: Chromecast does not work remote with this setup. Apart from that the Shim is not deprecated or anything, as it will always hold more features. So, I figured it to be a Roku client-side issue with the jellyfin addon/client. However, it also tends to consume the database Does the android (phone) app support direct play of hevc x265? Server dashboard tells me the file is being direct played, but the app itself claim it is transcoding. Currently Jellyfin only support transcoding from AV1 to another codec such as H264 and HEVC w/ and w/o hardware acceleration. 99. Very weird, just now got an upgrade from the old 4k stick to the new MAX one (not really worth it imho) and for some reason the PLEX app on it constantly fails to direct play 4k files that always were ok on the old stick. The only downside is it has 200GB SSD max for free tier, so you need to delete stuff when it reaches the limit. Problem disappears when media is getting transcoded. [deleted] • 2 yr. Not sure what's going on here, but Jellyfin is transcoding things due to "SubtitleCodecNotSupported". Unless told otherwise, Kodi will almost always direct play (receiving the file directly, unmodified) with no ffmpeg between it and playback. It can direct play all of my content, which is in a pretty healthy mix of formats. First it used to directplay the hevc files on edge but the video used to flicker, after googling some solution i uninstalled the HEVC extension from device manufacturer and Purchased the HEVC extension from microsoft but now the web player can't even DirectPlay it starts transcoding and the reason for transcoding is codec not supported. You should be fine without a GPU so long as all of your clients can direct play AVI. Can't play HDR10+ nor Dolby Vision files, and of course no Dolby Atmos because PS5 doesn't natively support it. 265 but it looks like Android playback is sometimes broken which is one of my main streaming devices. A ShieldTV (wired), an android phone (wifi) and this Windows computer (wifi). Is it a good idea to transcode all my media to H. Direct stream is converting the container, but not the encoding. Another video file was able to play, not directly. I'm testing direct play of HEVC MKV files to an LG C1. The issue is DV 5 is currently not supported, at all , in jellyfin. Playback info. Look at the dashboard, also try and different audio track on the rip. As you can see from the first table, if you use Kodi with either the Jellyfin for Kodi Addon or JellyCon Addon you can pretty much play anything without transcoding. It always ends up transcoding. Looking at Grafana the cpu does not stop If you allow transcoding and then watch something, you can go to the admin dashboard and see the currently playing media with a little info button. Would make setting up kodi even easier if jf was acting as the tv server too. Imo x264 should always be able to directstream, but I've come across behaviour I can't explain: Why does this (copied the log-file) mkv file directstream, but this one does transcode? Plex Local/Direct Play doesn’t work, but JellyFin does. Comparing codecs with another media file that is selected Not entirely true, as far as i understood mpv shim and the newer jellyfin media player are both based on the same core. You should see what is transcoded (audio or video). same media on Plex Server Direct Plays; One such example; The media is being converted into a format that is compatible with the device that is playing the media. And it's only $1. Here is my setup: HDHomeRun Flex 4K. Hoping this message finds you all well. 7. Client2 (used for testing): arch linux amd64. I tried them on Windows with my Arc A380 The Infuse app is what I'm currently using with my Jellyfin server and I have nothing but good things to say about it. This is a huge problem because mostly my Dec 18, 2023 · Lagging on Direct Play and Transcoding. But I have a friend who has a Roku tv and it’s direct stream or play, i thought both of them was the same. e. Not to take away at all from Swiftfin, just mentioning it's a good alternative option. But in all 3 cases, the Jellyfin server is acting as the intermediate between the client and the file. 1 direct playing is broken on android jellyfin app with files that has EAC3 audio, and since i can't roll back to 10. Default : Yes. That is true, however my goal is just to have an 4k HDR TV with FireTv Cube/Apple TV 4k streaming from my local Jellyfin server. 9x for HLS streaming. If you disable the normalization the problem is that your streams will most likely break whenever episodes switch and have different formats. I'm trying to directplay a series in my Samsung TV through DLNA, running latest jellyfin. Watch 2-3 tutorials reddit posts. I also have a copy of another film which only shows in black and white. Jelly’s players use MPV. I want to be able to configure these sets of following rules: When playing direct, no limits on bandwidth. Framerate: 25fps 42. 23. If my users are going to pay a monthly sub for Infuse 6, I'd almost they rather just "crowd fund"?my server and we could then either build a better more powerful transcoding capable server, or way more hard drives to store more It's not better, but people are feeling that Plex is moving away from self hosted media to streaming services. Raspberry pi 4 + Multiple users (outside of my LAN) + Direct stream. In 10. 50/m or something for Infuse Pro. This will force the API to return the proxy hostname. I use the tvheadend addon in jf in the rare case I want to watch tv through the jf app. DAS (Direct Attached Storage) QNAP TL-D800S <= 2 x SFF 8x6Gbs => TrueNas Scale [Share Samba] <= RJ45 1Gbs => Ubuntu Server CPU: I7 i7-8750H => Docker [Jellyfin] I'm experiencing significant stuttering issues with Jellyfin when playing a 4K video, and it struggles to Hey guys i am having problem playing my movies on edge. 2. I'm in the process of remuxing/reencoding all my files, and wanted to ask what the best codecs and containers would be. Using 2 kodi boxes with PlexKodiConnect, direct play. Swiching ffmpeg or accessing storage is easier with direct install. You do this by creating new parameters with either blank fields or "all" in Long answer: No, but you don't get to choose whether something is direct-streamed or transcoded - that depends on the media file specifications and the capabilities of your client. 5. This would be a nice feature though. Please assist in any solutions for this issue. Direct Stream will occur if the audio, container or subtitles happen to not be supported. I’m wondering if anyone has an Nvidia Shield Pro 2017 and can confirm Jellyfin will direct play EAC3 (without pass though)? I currently use Plex (and…. if Beam supports AC3 then that should play. Thanks for the consideration! I would say plex is like sublime-text: closed source but free, minimal and performant, while jellyfin is like atom: open source and slightly resource intensive. What are the pros and cons using one over the other? [UPDATE] Thank you all for your replies and detailed information. Here’s the overview: my Plex server (running off a windows pc) worked totally fine for me in-network at home with Local playback, and my friends could If I playback through jellyfin on Firefox I run into an issue with dropped frames for direct streaming. Please visit us at our new forums. frame= 483 fps=3. kodi. For some insane reason, Firefox doesn't support . Remote network is a cable modem hooked up to a router that the JF clients connect to. The files work on VLC player on the PC fine but not on tv or through iphone app. I am running a Jellyfin server from the follow spec'd device: There are times when I can play a file flawlessly (Spider-Man_log), but others when I am chugging at Using hardware encoding is easier to configure with direct install. Jellyfin is great if all you want to do is stream your media with no frills, no extras and no third party. So Jellyfin appears to be transcoding media that ought to be direct-play i. Media Player: ExoPlayer, Choolse player automatically. You could use this info to figure out why that particular media file requires transcoding. I'm using Jellyfin 10. Jul 5, 2023 · I use an Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max with Jellyfin installed through Amazon's app store. 1 audio track in direct play via jellyfin (running in a docker) on my LG TV. I get around 5-10 dropped frames every 20 seconds it seems. 9 % of my videos are with. 3g. i disabled the auto play and only allow plex to auto stream and the issue is gone. But is missing some big Plex features. It really depends on the media, but if the media is able to play drivest, Raspberry pi is perfect, especially in that size 4k. Kodi would make more sense for your use case (single user streaming from a local network). Transcoding (FFMPEG) logs would certainly be helpful for others to help out. The media file ends up being transcoded with Reasons: VideoCodecNotSupported. At the end of the day, I prefer sublime-text. "Extract Subtitles on the Fly" is enabled, and "Burn Subtitles" is set to image formats only. Reply. Some types of content like HEVC can sometimes only be played using fMP4 which I believe needs some processing when Dec 7, 2023 · FOR ANYONE READING IN THE FUTURE - Do not handle this with the proxy. 4 Mbps TS H264 AAC Reason for transcoding: VideoCodecNotSupported May 5, 2021 · All my video is direct-playable on my devices. Under the server networking settings, Firewall and Proxy Settings -> Published Server URIs, set it to "all=YOUR_HOSTNAME". Video stream is direct play, audio is transcoding. My files are MKV files with embedded SSA subtitles. Others all have problems about offline music, ui/ux, general ease to deploy relative to functionality given. My current server is capable of transcoding a few streams as welll. This means the container, video, audio and subtitles are all compatible with the client. I’ve ended up installing Jellyfin (Docker) and couldn’t be happier. 1. Devs didn’t mention the container issue at all. It transcodes on iOS both the app and Safari, but you can direct play it on the Infuse app. 7 on a Win10 64-bit PC, accessing files on a NAS through a Wireguard tunnel (hosted on a gigabit line) over a local 40 Meg residential connection. when testing the same video on plex i was getting the same result and searching around it looks like when using direct play, it will do this for some movies/tv shows. 5, nothing played with only that option selected. If you're sure that the content you're trying to play on the client should be playable without transcoding, turn transcoding off in the user settings within the Jellyfin server dashboard. I think MPV-Shim or Edge Chromium can handle HEVC direct play easily on a RX 5500XT. The welcome thread is available here, and the forum, as well I use a Roku 4K stick and all my movies are 264 mkv, AAC 5. Plex and Plexamp, it’s the only competent combo doing music selfhosted close to Spotify or Apple Music. Is there a way to check transcoding information on the android TV app itself? Again, server dashboard tells me its direct playing, but based on the cpu levels it seems to be This is from iOS perspective, I think Android has other good options. Transcoding is re-encoding the actual streams to another format. All of them are on default settings. Subtitle types. If I had to guess, the combination of clients and the files/codecs you're using are resulting in a direct stream, meaning that the server is passing the media through ffmpeg and giving you the result. 9 q=28. I have been running it in docker on a pi4. Quality will most likely be the best I would have to transcode subtitles on the fly within Jellyfin which means it would no longer be a direct play if using the H. Help. As for the other devices, maybe it just needs to transcode for those devices, unfortunately. It’s working perfectly for my purpose. 7 may i ask is there some kind of hot fix in server side or i need to wait for next update of android app? All of my Roku users started reporting a playback problem all of a sudden while I was/am on 10. If only jellyfin had better portfowarding like plex without running caddy i think it would be used more. Most major platforms now supported. Installation, updates, backups and reinstallations are way easier in Docker. Streaming to remote client. That being said, there is more to direct play than codecs. I believe this hardware is capable of video playing this file, but even if direct play fails there is no transcoding that is done as a fallback. I just have HDTV 1080p content or HEVC and I use only Direct play for all my users but my friends with a good internet connexion have a lot of lag. 7 may i ask is there some kind of hot fix in server side or i need to wait for next update of android app? Direct Play: The Jellyfin server acts as a proxy and sends the file as-is to the client without chunking over HTTP. Add a Comment. Hi, Some HEVC Media that I have on my server, lags while Direct play from Chrome. As the Android TV client improves it will likely begin to direct play more media types, so that could also be an alternative in the I'm looking to be able direct play all of my media, mostly for my users (most of which use browsers) and my NAS, which isn't able to hardware transcode. hello me again i have been posting about this issue for a while now without a clear answer. This one is unavoidable unless you use another player. 0 HDD. It would be simplier to just have one setting that always forces direct play. Things that I have tried. 2, in that range of checkboxes, the only one I had checked is Allow media playback. This can be found under Dashboard -> Users -> Select the user profile your client is logged into -> uncheck everything except "Allow media playback". tv/articles High CPU when direct streaming. The following things I have already tried while troubleshooting. Direct Play stutters and freezes. - Disable HVEC transcoding. Hi, since the latest upgrade to 10. ago. This is being played on an Nvidia Shield Pro. I'm reencoding all H265 to H264 That's likely at least part of the issue, since by default remote quality is set to 720p (either 2Mbps or 4Mbps, can't remember which). Direct Stream Live TV: Enabled and Disabled. Didn't matter if it was direct-play or direct-stream (either mkv container remux or audio transcode). On the client side i have tried the following. mkv containers natively, so direct streaming is required, rather than using direct play. It’ll eventually flow through to jelly. This means: The video and audio tracks are extracted from the original file; The streams are saved back into a compatible file container; and. These files direct play in Plex and Emby fine, but Jellyfin is transcoding them for some reason. It will not serve the file "directly" from the NAS, even if the client could use the same remote filesystem protocol that the I have EAC3 that direct plays in all 3 servers on my FireStick and on my Shield. Hello Everyone, I'll explain my current configuration and then my problem. 28 bitrate=N/A speed=0. When transcoding, limit at most to 1080p - 10 MBPS It also needs transcoding for adding the overlay icon, if you want it. 1 and Jellyfin does a conversion without transcoding of my audio because my soundbar is a 2. See: https://support. It shows direct streaming due to audio, which is 7. 165x. • 4 mo. Jellyfin Media Player on your computer should direct play, too. If you have the playback quality in the HTML player set below the bitrate of the original file, then Jellyfish transcodes it to a lower bitrate (and thus quality). If you want to host on your PC and do encoding/direct play, use Tailscale or something similar. My Streaming Stick and Streaming Stick+ both use the same version of Roku OS and only the Plus plays HEVC. I literally spend like 3-4 days trying to configure jelly to work with caddy for remote access and i couldnt make it work. There are tabs that hold the container parameters for the profile. Jellyfin for kodi. You do need your http header string for your device in order to do this. Make sure it's set to original/maximum. Here's the ffmpeg log. Finally if you use Plex to play dizqueTV, its DVR player does transcoding. Kodi will create a local library directly from the SMB shares. Recently I noticed its been using a lot of cpu for direct streaming. Also AV1 direct play is supported on most browsers. Firestick 4k MAX fails direct stream and transcodes. in the Jellyfin Android Mobile App, change the player to the Integrated Player. Yes, because quicksync use minimal power and subtitle only synchronized when I burn them to the video. To my knownledge, you can't use live tv at all through the kodi jf addon. ISSUE: direct play and direct stream buffer constantly, despite fast To paraphrase, Direct Play is when the file is 100% compatible with the target device, Direct Stream is when the container is incompatible with the device and it gets repackaged on-the-fly, and Transcoding is when the codec (audio or video) is incompatible with the device and it gets re-encoded on-the-fly. Direct Streaming a file uses very little processing power Go to Settings > Status > Dashboard. Sort by: truth_is_an_opinion. Still lags Server Installed on Windows 10 Direct play is just playing the file as is. The Infuse app is what I'm currently using with my Jellyfin server and I have nothing but good things to say about it. If your using jellyfin mpv shim you can still access the files via smb with the added benefit of progress tracking inside of Jellyfin. I always watch via SMB for this reason. It direct-plays on Windows app, Vivaldi browser (the only browser I tested), and Android app (I don't have on, tested it on NoxPlayer). . I direct play H. 3. I'll always recommend Jellyfin over plex for one simple reason: Jellyfin is fully self-hosted. Transcoding 4K HEVC to 4K H264 on the fly is very hard for your i7 3770. You own all your data, and it never gets held or controlled by anyone else's servers in the cloud. Hi Because I don't have too many resources on my server, I'm trying to direct play/stream everything. Especially when using Docker Compose. 8. ve dg cq db rs pi sm xy gy ci